Auction or private treaty
An auction sells certainty of timing and a public price. Private treaty sells discretion and control over everything except the date. What each route costs, and when each is the right one, for a car, a watch or a painting.
There is a moment in every great sale when the room goes quiet. The bidding has slowed to two telephones, the auctioneer has stopped looking at the floor, and the specialists on the bank of phones are speaking very softly into their receivers. Whatever happens in the next half minute will be published within the hour, and every collector of the category will know it by breakfast.
The alternative takes place in a different kind of room: a viewing by appointment, a private showroom, an inspection in a warehouse with the car on a lift. Nobody announces a price. The object changes hands, and the world learns of it, if at all, years later. Most owners of something significant will at some point choose between these two routes. The choice is less about fees than it first appears, but the fees are where any honest account must begin.
What the buyer pays
The buyer's premium is the one cost every house publishes. At Christie's, following a revision in September 2025, it stands in New York at 27 per cent of the hammer price up to 1.5 million dollars, 22 per cent from 1.5 million to 8 million, and 15 per cent above that. Sotheby's revised its own schedule on 13 February 2026: 28 per cent up to 1.5 million pounds in London or 2 million dollars in New York, 22 per cent up to 6 million pounds or 8 million dollars, and 15 per cent beyond. The Antiques Trade Gazette calculated that on a hammer of 1.5 million pounds the premium rose from 370,000 to 420,000 pounds.
Cars are sold on a lighter scale. At RM Sotheby's London sale on 31 October, at The Peninsula, the premium is 15 per cent up to 200,000 pounds and 12.5 per cent above, plus VAT, with memorabilia at 20 per cent. Broad Arrow charges 12 per cent on the first 250,000 dollars and 10 per cent above at its American sales, and 15 per cent and 12.5 per cent at its European ones, plus VAT. A buyer bidding on a significant painting should add roughly a quarter to the hammer before raising a paddle; a buyer bidding on a significant car, between a tenth and an eighth.
What the seller pays
The seller's commission is a different matter. It is rarely published as a schedule, because at the level that matters it is negotiated. Guides to consigning suggest that a standard consignment at a major house might pay around 15 per cent of the hammer price, together with charges for insurance, photography, cataloguing and marketing, and that for an important consignment those terms can be reduced or waived altogether.
This is where the comparison with private treaty becomes difficult. In a private sale the seller usually agrees a net figure, the intermediary is paid a commission or a margin, and the buyer pays a single price with no premium on top. The total cost of the transaction may be lower or higher than at auction, but it is almost never visible, and it is not comparable at face value. What can be compared is what each route guarantees, and what each exposes.
Reserves and guarantees
An auction protects the seller in two ways. The first is the reserve. Broad Arrow's published conditions are typical of the car houses: every lot is offered subject to a confidential reserve unless stated otherwise, the reserve is always at or below the low estimate, the consignor may lower it at any time but never raise it, and the house may sell below it at its own discretion.
The second is the guarantee, in which the house or a third party commits in advance to a minimum price. In the art market it has become the rule rather than the exception. According to ArtTactic, guaranteed lots made up 72.9 per cent of evening sale volume between January and May 2025, the highest share since its analysis began in 2016, while the average return earned by guarantors fell from 9.5 to 7.2 per cent. A guaranteed lot is, in effect, a private sale with a public auction attached. The price has been agreed before the room has seen it.
The private departments
The great houses no longer treat private sales as an afterthought. Christie's sold 1.5 billion dollars privately in 2025, about 24 per cent of its 6.2 billion dollar total, including seventeen works above 15 million dollars, against thirteen the year before; half of its private buyers were new to the channel. Sotheby's sold 1.2 billion privately within consolidated sales of 7.0 billion, and has sold between 1.1 and 1.3 billion privately each year since 2020. Its invitation only exhibition The Apartment, in London, has become a quiet institution. Phillips reported private sales up 66 per cent.
In cars the shift is sharper. Broad Arrow's private sales in 2025 exceeded its auction total for the first time. RM Sotheby's runs private sales from Los Angeles, London and Dallas, with showrooms in New York and Los Angeles, and offers its sealed format in which bidders see only their own position and every party remains anonymous. On its sealed lots there is no buyer's premium, and the final price stays confidential.
Choosing the route
Auction is the right route when the object is well known, the comparables are recent, and competition is likely to carry the price beyond what any single buyer would offer privately. It is right when the seller needs a date, an estate needs closing, or a public result will itself add to the value of a collection. Its risk is the one that cannot be undone: a lot that fails to sell carries that fact with it for years.
Private treaty is the right route when the object is so rare that the buyers can be counted on one hand, when its condition or history needs to be explained slowly, or when the owner simply prefers not to be known to be selling. Its risk is the absence of price discovery, which is why it depends on an adviser who knows what the last three comparable objects actually made.
The house works on both sides of this line, and we do not regard one route as superior. The right answer depends on the object, the owner and the year. Some objects belong under a rostrum, and some belong in a private room with three people in it. What is never right is to choose by habit, or by whichever adviser happened to call first.
- Source: Grossman LLP Art Law Blog, Spring 2026 Auction Season: Examining Recent Changes in Buyer's Premiums, May 2026
- Source: Antiques Trade Gazette, Sotheby's raises buyer's premium to 28% at the lower tier, February 2026
- Source: MyArtBroker, A guide to auction versus private sale commission fees, July 2026
- Source: RM Sotheby's, The London Auction 2026, bidders' conditions of business, October 2026
- Source: Broad Arrow Auctions, Conditions of Sale, October 2026
- Source: ArtTactic, Auction Guarantee Analysis, July 2025
- Source: Artdependence, Christie's projects 2025 global sales of $6.2 billion, December 2025
- Source: Artdependence, Sotheby's projects 2025 consolidated sales of $7 billion, December 2025
- Source: USA Art News, Private sales are surging as auction houses lean into exclusive selling, April 2026
- Source: Hagerty Newsroom, Broad Arrow exceeds $624 million in total transactions in 2025, December 2025
- Source: RM Sotheby's, Private Sales and How Sealed Bidding Works, October 2026