What the indices say
Knight Frank, Art Basel and UBS, WatchCharts, Hagerty and HAGI each publish a number for the year. Read together, they describe a market that is calm on average and anything but calm at the top.
Every April a single figure travels further than any other in the world of collecting. This year it was a small one. The twentieth edition of The Wealth Report, published by Knight Frank on 23 April 2026, recorded that its Luxury Investment Index had closed 2025 down 0.4 per cent, which the authors described as a year of stabilisation after two years of losses. Within a week the number had been quoted in Mumbai, Nairobi and Milan, usually as a verdict.
It is not a verdict. It is an average of ten very different markets, and the most useful thing an index can do for a serious buyer is show where the average conceals the movement. We read five families of index through the year. Each measures something slightly different, and the disagreements between them are where the information lies. None of them is a forecast, and none was designed to be.
The Knight Frank basket
The Knight Frank index follows cars, watches, art, jewellery, coloured diamonds, handbags, coins, furniture, whisky and wine. Over ten years it has risen 38.6 per cent. Over 2025 the components pulled in opposite directions. Classic cars fell 3.7 per cent and whisky 10.9 per cent. The principal fine wine benchmark, the Fine Wine 100, lost 2.5 per cent and stands almost a quarter below its 2022 peak. Hermès Birkin and Kelly bags slipped 0.2 per cent.
Against that, watches rose. The report draws on WatchCharts, whose overall market index gained 5.1 per cent, with Rolex up 4.6 per cent and Patek Philippe up 12.1 per cent. Fancy coloured diamonds were described as relatively stable, though the blue stones were the exception: the 9.51 carat Mellon Blue sold for 25.6 million dollars and the 10.03 carat Mediterranean Blue for 21.5 million. Combined fine art sales at the major auction houses rose 11 per cent. The authors' own summary is the right one: buyers are increasingly disciplined, favouring rarity and value.
Art, measured by turnover
The Art Basel and UBS Global Art Market Report, written by Clare McAndrew of Arts Economics and released on 12 March 2026, is not a price index at all. It measures turnover, and in 2025 turnover returned to growth: global sales of about 59.6 billion dollars, up 4 per cent, across an estimated 41.5 million transactions. Dealers accounted for 34.8 billion, up 2 per cent. Public auction sales reached 20.7 billion, up 9 per cent, and auction sales above ten million dollars grew by 30 per cent.
The United States held 44 per cent of the market by value at 26.0 billion dollars, the United Kingdom 18 per cent at 10.5 billion, and China 14 per cent at 8.5 billion. Online sales fell to 9.2 billion, the lowest figure since 2019, while art fairs rose to 35 per cent of dealer turnover. The point to carry away is that the recovery began at the top. The great pictures came back to the rooms first, and the middle of the market followed slowly, if at all.
The watch indices
Watches are the one passion asset with something close to a daily price. WatchCharts builds its indices from the secondary market, and its record of the last five years is a useful lesson in how quickly sentiment can travel. According to an assessment published by Hilco in the summer of 2026, the average resale price of a Rolex rose from about 7,185 dollars before the pandemic to a peak of about 17,206 dollars in March 2022, then corrected from late 2022 until a floor was reached between late 2024 and early 2025.
Since then the direction has been upward. In the twelve months to February 2026, the WatchCharts overall index rose about 8.2 per cent, Rolex about 7.9 per cent and Patek Philippe 16.2 per cent, while Breitling fell 1.1 per cent in the same update. The spread between brands matters more than the index. A recovery that favours Patek Philippe and the discontinued steel references of Audemars Piguet is a recovery in scarcity, and scarcity is rarely spread evenly.
Cars, by Hagerty and by HAGI
For cars there are two quite different instruments. Hagerty, which insures a large share of the American collector fleet, publishes a monthly Market Rating built from auction results, insurance quotes and private sales data. In January 2026 it fell to 58.28, its lowest level in nearly fifteen years, having declined in 37 of the 43 months since its peak in the summer of 2022. Its Blue Chip Index, which follows twenty five seven figure cars in excellent condition, fell 1.3 per cent in the same update. By June the rating stood at 58.59, and Hagerty's measure of private sales activity had reached its lowest point in more than five years.
Then came Monterey. In August 2026 the auctions of Car Week sold 844 of 1,124 lots for 747.9 million dollars by Hagerty's own tally, a record, with an average price of 866,107 dollars and eleven cars above ten million. A national rating near a fifteen year low and a record week on the Monterey Peninsula are not a contradiction. They describe two markets that happen to share a vocabulary.
The Historic Automobile Group International, HAGI, has published its indices monthly since 2008: a Top index of exceptional historic cars, separate series for rare Ferrari and Porsche, the Top index excluding both, and indices for classic Mercedes, Lamborghini and BMW. Its fact sheets sit in a members' area behind a password. That the most closely watched measure of the upper car market is itself private says a good deal about the market it measures.
What an index cannot price
An index is an average, and at the level where our members buy, averages do not trade. Two cars of the same model and year, one with matching numbers and an unbroken file and one with a replacement engine and a gap in the eighties, are not the same asset and never have been. The same is true of a watch with its original dial and papers against one that has been polished and serviced into anonymity, or of a painting with an exhibition history against one that has spent forty years in a corridor.
Indices are also built from what is public. They see the hammer, not the conversation that preceded it, and they cannot see the private treaty sale at all. In a market where the most significant objects increasingly change hands without a catalogue, an index describes the visible part of the water. It is a fair portrait of the surface, and a poor guide to the depth beneath it.
How the house reads them
We read the indices as weather rather than as price. They tell us whether a room will be generous or cautious, whether a seller should wait a season, whether a buyer has the advantage in a given category this year. They never tell us what a specific car, watch or picture is worth. That judgement is made the old way, object by object, with the archive, the specialist and the comparable sales that actually resemble it.
Inside Korthos, our market intelligence follows each of these series as it is published, set beside the auction results that matter, the private sales that can be confirmed, and our reading of all three. A falling average and a rising top are not a mixed signal. For anyone buying the rare thing, with patience and the right advice, they are the clearest signal there is.
- Source: Knight Frank, Knight Frank Luxury Investment Index: luxury holds steady, The Wealth Report 2026, April 2026
- Source: Outlook Business (PTI), Luxury investment: Impressionist art sees max 13.6 pc price rise, whisky rates down 11 pc, April 2026
- Source: Art Basel, The Art Basel and UBS Global Art Market Report 2026, March 2026
- Source: Hilco Global, Collateral in Question: A Mid 2026 Assessment of the Luxury Watch Segment for Asset Based Lenders, August 2026
- Source: Hagerty Media, Hagerty Collector Car Market Rating Sinks to 15 Year Low, January 2026
- Source: CarPro, Collector car markets cool off a bit, July 2026
- Source: Motorious, Monterey Car Week 2026 Auction Results, August 2026
- Source: Historic Automobile Group International, Data and analysis, October 2026