The quiet market
A large part of the trade in significant cars, watches and pictures happens without a catalogue, a hammer or a published price. What the figures reveal about that quiet market, and why a house exists for it.
The most interesting sales of the year are often the ones nobody reports. A car leaves a heated garage on a covered transporter on a weekday morning. A painting is taken down from a wall in one city and hung in another, and the only document that records the price is an invoice in a lawyer's file. A watch passes across a table in a hotel suite, is turned over once, and goes into a different pocket.
None of these transactions appears in a sale total, a press release or an index. Together they form what the trade calls the private market, and what we prefer to call the quiet one. It is not small, it is not new, and in the last two years it has been growing faster than the market everyone can see. The evidence for that is partial, as it must be, but it is consistent, and much of it comes from the auction houses themselves.
Counting what is not counted
The quiet market cannot be measured directly, but it can be measured at its edges. The Art Basel and UBS Global Art Market Report puts global art sales in 2025 at about 59.6 billion dollars. Of that, dealers accounted for 34.8 billion, close to three fifths of the whole. Dealers do not publish their prices. A majority of the world's art, by value, is therefore sold at figures that nobody outside the transaction will ever know.
The auction houses themselves sold just under 4.2 billion dollars of art privately in the same year. In cars, Hagerty's widely quoted total of 4.8 billion dollars for 2025 counts auctions and online platforms only; dealers and private treaty sit outside it. The one house to publish a clean comparison is Broad Arrow, whose private sales in 2025 reached more than 281 million dollars across 190 transactions and, for the first time, exceeded its 257 million dollars at auction.
Why sellers stay quiet
There are good reasons for an object to stay out of a catalogue. A seller may not wish to be known to be selling, for reasons of family, business or simple temperament. A collection may be in the middle of being reshaped, and one sale announced in public invites a dozen unwanted offers for everything else. An estate may need to settle quietly before the heirs have agreed what to keep.
Above all there is the risk of failure. A lot that does not reach its reserve is published as unsold, and that fact travels with the object. The next time it is offered, every serious buyer knows it was offered before and what the room thought of it. A private approach that does not succeed leaves no record at all. For a car, a watch or a picture whose value rests partly on its reputation, that difference can be worth more than any commission.
Why buyers prefer it
Buyers have their own reasons. The first is competition. At auction a buyer bids against everyone in the room; in a private sale, against the seller's expectations alone. The second is cost. RM Sotheby's, for instance, charges no buyer's premium on lots sold through its sealed format, and keeps the final price confidential, so that buyer, seller and underbidders remain anonymous throughout.
The third is time. A private sale allows an inspection without a crowd, a second opinion from an engineer or a conservator, a look at the archive and, where needed, a pause while a question is answered. An auction allows a preview and a deadline. For an object with any complexity in its history, the slower route is usually the safer one. It is also the route on which a buyer can walk away without anyone knowing that he looked.
The houses learned it first
The great auction houses understood this long ago, and have been building quiet rooms beside their salerooms ever since. Christie's sold 1.5 billion dollars privately in 2025, close to a quarter of its total, including seventeen works above 15 million dollars, and reported that half of its private buyers were new to the channel. Sotheby's has sold between 1.1 and 1.3 billion dollars privately in each year since 2020.
The form those sales take has become more refined. This spring Sotheby's sent some two hundred invitations to its exhibition The Apartment in London, a private presentation of around 40 million dollars of art and design; about half of its twelve works had sold before it closed. Phillips reported private sales up 66 per cent last year. In cars, RM Sotheby's and Gooding Christie's each run private sales alongside their catalogues. The quiet market is not a rival to the auction world. Increasingly, it is the auction world, out of hours.
The cost of silence
Discretion has a price of its own, and an honest account must name it. A private sale has no public competition to test the figure. It depends entirely on the knowledge of the people arranging it: what comparable objects have actually made, what condition and provenance are worth, and what a particular buyer has been looking for, sometimes for years.
That is why the quiet market depends on the loud one. The public results of Monterey, Rétromobile or a November evening sale in New York are the reference points against which every private price is set. A house that works in private must therefore watch the public rooms more closely than anyone, and must be prepared to tell an owner, plainly, when an object belongs in a catalogue instead.
What a house is for
This is the part of the market a house like ours exists for. Not access to what is listed, which anyone can read, but knowledge of what is not: which objects might come to market if the right approach were made, which buyers are looking and with what patience, and how an object can change hands without either party becoming a story.
The work is unglamorous. It consists of verification, archive extracts, independent inspection, introductions made carefully and confidences kept for years. It produces no headlines, by design, and the best of it is never mentioned again by anyone involved. In a market where the most significant things are increasingly sold without an audience, the most valuable thing a house can offer is to be the room in which they are.
- Source: Art Basel, The Art Basel and UBS Global Art Market Report 2026, March 2026
- Source: Hagerty Media, By the Numbers: The Collector Car Market in 2025, December 2025 (updated January 2026)
- Source: Motorious, Hagerty Sees Continued Momentum in Classic Car Market Heading Into 2026, January 2026
- Source: Hagerty Newsroom, Broad Arrow exceeds $624 million in total transactions in 2025, December 2025
- Source: RM Sotheby's, Bidder information for sealed lots and Private Sales, October 2026
- Source: USA Art News, Private sales are surging as auction houses lean into exclusive selling, April 2026
- Source: Artdependence, Christie's projects 2025 global sales of $6.2 billion, December 2025